Jump To Navigation
Reputation. Experience. Success

Articles About the Firm

Court of Appeals Allows Class Action Against Insurer
By: Greg Land
Published in Daily Report, July 2010

In a resoundIng defeat for the defendant insurance company, the georgia Court of appeals has upheld a lower courts decision allowing a class action to proceed on behalf of potentially hundreds of thousands of customers who bought credit insurance when financing their vehicles, but whoin cases in which the loans were paid off early or the cars were wrecked and the loans canceledwere not provided refunds of those premiums.
» READ MORE

Ford settles as jury considers damages: Woman Paralyzed in '05 Wreck; Design Flaws Blamed
By: Greg Land
Published in Daily Report, December 2009

Already on the hook for the lion's share of a $17.7 million judgment and waiting for a decision from a jury that was out considering punitive damages, Ford Motor Co. decided to settle with a couple who sued following a Christmas 2005 wreck that left the woman paralyzed.
» READ MORE

Children win in airport death suit: Family of construction worker who was run over, killed by dump truck is awarded $5.47 million
By: Andy Peters
Published in Daily Report, November 2009

Following a fatal accident on the construction site of the Atlanta airport's new international terminal, lawyers from two firms filed a wrongful-death suit against a dump-truck company. last month they obtained a $5.47 million verdict on behalf of the victim's four young children.
» READ MORE

$13M win against DaimlerChrysler to keep firm busy
By: Zach Lowe
Published in Daily Report July 2008

Lawyers at Butler, Wooten & Fryhofer find themselves in the middle of a nationally watched punitive damages case after a closely divided Tennessee Supreme Court reversed a lower court and upheld a $13.4 million award to a mother whose infant son died in a 2001 car crash.
» READ MORE

The Squire of Muscogee County: James Butler is as prepared as Winston Churchill and as down-to-earth as Atticus Finch
By: Kenna Simmons
Published in Georgia Super Lawyers 2008 March 2008

The first time I ever stood in front of a jury," James Butler says, "I knew I had died and gone to heaven." In the 30 years since that celestial moment, Butler has won four verdicts worth over $100 million each, while his firm, Butler Wooten & Fryhofer, has notched more than $1 billion in its top 10 wins.
» READ MORE

Loan insurance class action settles for $45 million
By: Alyson M. Palmer
Published in Daily Report, November 2007

A nationwide class action over insurance policies that consumers buy when they take out retail loans has settled for $45 million.
» READ MORE

Ford takes $13 million verdict to Ga. high court
By: Alyson M. Palmer
Published in Daily Report, September 2007

Arguments over A death-row inmate's mental capacity and a $13 million judgment against Ford Motor Co. highlighted the opening of the September term of the Supreme Court of Georgia.
» READ MORE

The Advocate: Attorney Jim Butler creates a scholarship that supports the future of public interest law
By: Allyson Mann (MA '92)
Printed in: The University of Georgia Magazine, June 2006

In the lobby of Columbus law firm Butler, Wooten and Fryhofer, there are two framed photographs from the 1962 movie "To Kill a Mockingbird." Chosen by Jim Butler (ABJ '72, JD '77), the images are of Atticus Finch as played by Gregory Peck. In one, Finch argues his case before the jury while his client-a black man falsely accused of raping a white woman in a small, Depression-era Southern town-sits in the background. In the other, Finchwalks out of the courtroom while the audience stands, demonstrating that he's won their respect by proving his client's innocence despite losing the case. "That's the moment when I first started thinking about becoming a lawyer," says Butler...
» READ MORE

Butler Wins $105M Verdict in Chrysler Seat Back Case
By: Robin McDonald
Published in Fulton County Daily Report, December 2004

A Tennessee jury has socked DaimlerChrysler Corp. for $105.5 million after finding that a baby's 2001 death was caused by a faulty minivan seat.
» READ MORE

State's Biggest Jury Award
By: Ben Schmitt
Published in Daily Report, December 1998

A Gwinnett jury award this month left all others in Georgia in the dust. The $454 million in compensatory and punitive damages was a victory for investors who attacked Time Warner's management of Six Flags Over Georgia, saying it cost them money.
» READ MORE

Six Flags Verdict: $454 Million: Gwinnet Jury Hits Time Warner with $257 Million Judgement in Punitive Damages
By: Ben Schmitt
Published in Fulton County Daily Report, December 1998

The jury in an investors' suit over the operation of Six Flags Over Georgia on Monday delivered the second of two body blows to the park's former manager Time Warner--a one-two punch that totaled $454 million.
» READ MORE

Firm Whips GM, Wants More: Lawyer in Ga. Case With Similar Facts Predicts Repeat of Big Alabama Award
By: Emily Heller
Published in Fulton County Daily Report, June 1996

A Columbus plaintiffs firm renowned for winning huge jury verdicts says its latest one, a $150 million award from an Alabama jury against General Motors Corp., increases the likelihood of success in two similar suits in Georgia.
» READ MORE

Putting GM Verdict in Historical Context: How Biggest Win in State Stacks Up
By: Paul Kvinta
Published in Fulton County Daily Report, February 1993

If there were a verdict Hall of Fame, what place of honor would last week's 105.24 million Fulton State Court award against General Motors Corp. command?
» READ MORE

Punitive Damages Cap Under Attack: Plaintiffs Want Verdict To Stand
By: John L. Jackson
Published in Fulton County Daily Report, April 1990

The recent assault on the 1987 Tort Reform Act has not yet lifted the $250,000 cap on punitive damages. But personal injury lawyer James E. Butler Jr. attacked the cap on constitutional grounds Thursday, citing recent court decisions that whittle away at limits on punitive damages.
» READ MORE

Sending Defense Lawyers a Message: Can Opponents Counter James Butler's Closing?
By: S. Richard Gard Jr.
Published in Fulton County Daily Report, Sept 1988

Plaintiff's attorney James E. Butler Jr.'s ability to put an entire industry on trial in an isolated torts case continues to confound the insurance defense bar.
» READ MORE

Success Stories

$17,716,401 Verdict / Auto Product Liability / Ford Explorer Rear Restraint System / Lap Only Seat Belt

12/18/2009 Wheeler v. Ford Motor Company, et al., State Court, Clayton County, Georgia.

Plaintiffs Lynn and Douglas Wheeler won their design defect and failure to warn claims against Ford Motor Company relating to the 2002 Ford Explorer. On Christmas morning 2005, 58 year old Lynn Wheeler was on her way to church with her family. Lynn Wheeler was seated in the rear center seat of her son’s 2002 Ford Explorer, wearing the lap-only seat belt Ford installed for that seating position. Two of Lynn Wheeler’s grandchildren were in child seats on either side of her. As they entered a curve on Noah’s Ark Road, a 2-door Eagle Talon coupe driven by John C. Stanley crossed the centerline and struck the Explorer head-on.

$5,470,000 Verdict/Wrongful Death

10/23/09 Pitts v. A&G Trucking. Inc., et al., State Court of DeKalb County, Georgia.

Plaintiffs, four minor children, recovered for the death of their father, who was killed by a dump truck driver while the decedent was working as a "spotter" or "flag man" on the runway expansion at Hartsfield Jackson Atlanta International Airport. According to eye-witnesses, the driver of the dump truck was talking on her cell phone or CB radio and was given a stop signal by the deceased.

$45,000,000 Settlement | Credit Insurance/Consumer Rights Class Action

10/31/07 Toole v. J.M.I.C. Life Insurance Company, Superior Court of Muscogee County, Georgia

Plaintiff Toole represented a class of people who prepaid J.M.I.C. Life Insurance Company premiums for credit life and disability insurance policies when they purchased vehicles. J.M.I.C. Life Insurance Company contractually promised to refund any unearned premium if class members paid off the insured loans before the five-year term had expired, but failed to do so when they paid off the insured loans early.

$105,500,000 Verdict | Defective Automobile

11/23/04 Flax v. Daimler Chrysler Corporation and Louis A. Stockell, Jr., Circuit Court for Davidson County, Tennessee

More Verdicts

Columbus
105 13th Street
P.O. Box 2766
Columbus, GA 31902
FAX 706.323.2962
706.322.1990
1.800.233.4086

Atlanta
2719 Buford Highway
Atlanta, GA 30324
FAX 404.321.1713
404.321.1700
1.800.242.2962


FirmSite® by FindLaw, a Thomson Reuters business.

With offices in Atlanta and Columbus, Georgia, the attorneys at Butler, Wooten & Fryhofer, LLP represent the seriously injured throughout Georgia, including the cities of Atlanta, Columbus, Marietta, Smyrna, Roswell, Gainesville, Peachtree City, Forest Park, Riverdale, Lagrange, Macon, and Savannah. Our lawyers have handled accident and defective product claims nationwide, including Alabama, Arizona, California, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Kansas, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nevada, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, West Virginia and Wyoming.